WARNING! SPOILERS AND LONG, HEAVY RANTING FOR ZETA GUNDAM! (Because that’s all a blog really is.)
SCROLL ALL THE WAY TO THE BOTTOM IF YOU WANT THE SUMMARY OF THIS ENTIRE TEXT!
And if you have a problem with my structure, grammar or spelling, like… stop reading. This is just something I had to get off of my chest, badly, before my head could fall off or my heart might stop from the agony of keeping my frustrations to myself.
The biggest problem: since these are movies, not episodes, the creators try to use cinematic conveniences used in films to rush between sequences, like background noise and decorations, and uniforms worn by characters in the background. An animated feature isn’t filmed on a camera. There is no lens to focus on the foreground and background alternatively, so there’s no subtle way of showing the audience where and when the sequence is without static shots, wide shots, detail shots and reaction shots.
Hayao Miyazaki knows this very well. Can you imagine seeing this scene with only the main characters taking up a majority of each frame, and sped up to show only the beginning and end of the journey? I can, and it’s not good. Instead, seeing this scene, we know the space, we know the world, and we feel the time that our characters’ journey takes.
In a film, someone can see, far in the distance of a three-dimensional room, a clock above a water cooler. Two symbols of time and place, out of focus to show distance. Immediately, the audience understands this setting without asking about it, or even thinking about it.
Unless you can mimic the focus blur well enough or use dramatic exaggerations of a room’s proportions in an animated feature, the audience has no scale of depth. Your clock is painted, so unless you’ve scaled down a very large office scenery background to fit the frame, nobody can read the hands. Time and dimension are lost, so when we cut to this scene, with a speaker in the foreground and a strategically placed set of background elements, they are useless and confusing without being brought to the audience’s direct attention.
Heirs to the Stars has the same beginning as the series. Since we had two episodes to establish the main character and three more to explain why his situation is fucked, we have a steady start for a movie.
Here’s a little bit of what happens between our beginning and end. Kamille pulls Quattro onto the airship, narrowly escaping the massive nuclear explosion that kills the unfortunate pursuers left to grumble at each other. CUT! Amuro’s kissing Fraw’s cheek. What? There’s an intercom. Amuro guides Katz, who needs to use the restroom, through a door. Okay? Katz was faking. Why? They’re outside running towards a plane.
Can you see the confusion? I am thrust relentlessly from one intense situation to another without a moment’s notice, without a clue to what has just happened in Amuro and Katz’s side of the plot, and I only have seconds to assemble where they are and what they’re doing before the next sequence begins.
What should’ve happened before my eyes, instead: showing that the danger has passed momentarily for Quattro and Kamille, cutting to a visual description of the situation that Amuro and Katz are in. They’re in an airport. They’re making sure that Fraw and her foster kids make it to their scheduled flight. A man is watching them from a safe distance, incognito. Amuro is aware of the man’s presence, and tells Katz to pretend to need to use the restroom. They casually make their way to the other end of the building, where they exit in secrecy. We’re outside. The characters are outside too. Sound effects and the behaviors of other animated characters in the background alone aren’t enough to build an entire atmosphere, and they’re not enough to establish a situation.
Finally, at the end, I feel that all of our heroes are safe. There’s an image of two mobile suits in the sky. Amuro and Char are reunited. It’s big, it’s pretty, it’s emotional. The entire sequence was stretched out and represented by new, clean animation to replace the original visuals from the show. It’s a great visual to end a first act, no matter how rushed and uncomfortable that first act may have been. The actual final shots are so much better in pace and quality than the rest of the movie, it is the saving grace.
Lovers, part two, starts where we left off. Amuro finds that he has an admirer. This woman wants so badly for Amuro to reach his greatest potential, at the cost of bucking heads with Kamille. She’s a wonderful character and the force that eventually bonds Amuro and Kamille.
There is also another love interest to introduce. Four is a troubled youth, just like Kamille. They are forced to be enemies, but are drawn to each other and wish to become lovers.
In the series, Four wants her memories back, and she can’t be away from the villains long enough without having to go back for her medication, and everyone she’s ever known has abused her to make her into a fierce weapon. Despite all of the things holding her away, she falls in love with Kamille, and tries to get away from the Titans to be with him. While Kamille and Four are away from each other, Kamille sees his jealous friend, Fa, every day, and he has emotional conflict between the emotions he has for Four and the emotions Fa has for Kamille. It’s a wonderful trio of sadness with comedic moments, that ends with someone dying, and Kamille’s entire world being flipped upside-down all over again. Four’s death and Kamille’s horrible experience are also witnessed by Char and Amuro. They both know Kamille’s pain all too well, and Amuro blames Char for not protecting Kamille from the same experience that they shared during the One Year War. Kamille’s relationship is also the inspiration for why he tries so damn hard to persuade other misguided characters from fighting and dying for the wrong reasons.
In the middle movie, Four meets Kamille and they talk a bit. They’re forced to fight each other in mobile suits. Four gets shot while preparing Kamille a rocket to return to space. The boy continues life, as if someone he loved with all of his heart hadn’t sacrificed her own life for his sake. I realize that it takes time to build up the appropriate emotional depth that these characters originally had, but speeding through Four’s life and cutting her entire story in half makes her pointless. She might as well not have been in the movie at all.
So, the movie continues, there are visuals of mobile suit violence, the heroes are in need of help, and they’re helped out at the last minute by Haman. It ends with Axis swarming the AEUG fleet, and the promise of the two joining forces to defeat the villains.
Better ending: Four isn’t shot in the fucking face, and Kamille makes it to space. He saves Char from burning up in the atmosphere during a battle by using his mobile suit, just like in the show. Back on Earth, Kamille and Char meet Amuro again, and Kamille stumbles upon the secret base where the Titans are experimenting on Four, just like in the show. My heart strings are pulled, and Four dies in Kamille’s hands. Amuro screams at Char. END.
The final movie, Love is the Pulse of the Stars, is… ugh. Battles, battles, battles galore. Jared fights in one mobile suit for this moment, and the next he’s in another. When did he switch up?
Reccoa is captured by Paptimus, and she falls in love with him. There was no time for her to even get to know him. She heard the man’s name once, in the previous movie, and thought he was an honorable tactician. She’s so frustrated that Quattro doesn’t pay her enough attention, and goes to Paptimus instead. The show featured a very dramatic scene in which Reccoa bears her heart to the static lieutenant. The movie completely fails to show that Quattro was like that at all. There’s even a scene in one of these movies that shows Quattro and Reccoa having a romantic moment. So I’m confused why Reccoa is betraying all of her friends for a man she’s never met, with the excuse that Char didn’t love her enough.
One of the smartest things a person can do with a complicated story is plan out fifty episodes. A story arc can last a month, so in each episode, the directors and writers come up with inventive ways to make sure the audience remembers what happened last time, without treading the same waters, and they constantly provide new material to make the story progress at the same time.
In one episode, the good guys visit Haman to ask for help. Char doesn’t like asking for help from Haman, because he knows what a treacherous bitch she is, and starts a ruckus. Haman and the rest of Axis duke it out with the heroes, because of Char. In a following episode, the villains show up and stir some trouble with Axis, so Haman and Char set aside their differences. At the same time, Haman is planning with Paptimus to use his faction to start a coup against the main villain force. There’s secret war tactic and treachery in the works, and we see how vile Haman is, to pit two teams of characters against each other and lie to absolutely everyone, in the name of Zeon’s resurrection.
The movie doesn’t give the audience time to understand Haman’s tactics. She’s fighting AEUG, but the Titans are here, so she’ll be friends with AEUG, but she’s making a deal with a bad guy, and he’s fighting other bad guys, and… I’m lost, because the movie doesn’t take the time to show me that Haman has a master plan. I just know that she has an end to meet, and she’s making a lot of deals. Who is she lying to? Is she even lying to begin with? Who does she trust? Is she the puppeteer or the puppet? Who is the good guy? I DON’T KNOW!
Wong Lee is a businessman who funds the militant anti-Titan forces, which consists of the heroes of our series. It is very important that we know just how important this movement is to the world in which our characters live. The leader of a corporation who beats subordinate pilots for not following orders and barks amateur orders to war heroes and veterans tries to maintain as much control as he can, because he knows that his company’s money is going into a small group of rebels that has a lofty chance in freeing the human race of a galactic dictatorship. Either the operation floats, and the Titans are defeated, or he and everyone else will let the galaxy fall into immeasurable despair. He’s important, in the series.
In the movies, he’s just annoying. He doesn’t even have the air of someone with so much weight on his shoulders. He’s just a guy with a name and a suit, and he occasionally says something that a person in a suit would say.
More battles, no time to rest, Haman’s talking to Paptimus, she magically shows up at the villains’ space station and tries to kill the lead bad guy, there’s a battle, Paptimus and Haman magically show up at the lead bad guy’s next center of operations, Katz has a genuine moment of character advancement, lead bad guy dies, Paptimus blames Haman, more battles, the underdeveloped Jared dies forgetting that he has a revenge pact with Kamille, Katz dies after his love interest dies to save his life a few minutes ago, half the damn cast dies… it’s tiring and boring.
Finally, it ends. Again, an ending that is so beautiful compared the the rest of the movie, that I have to even wonder if it’s even the same damn movie I’ve been watching. I can now choose between the original ending, in which Kamille is in a vegetative state and I get a well rounded tragedy, or the new ending, in which Kamille is okay so that he and Fa can live their lives together. Like my Multi-Buffy-verse theory, both can be acceptable if I want to come up with a logical explanation, but it’s just an excuse for me to say that I want to keep both possibilities at the same time.
The bottom line is, these movies want to show a great television series in compact form, and they rush to do it. This sloppiness takes away some of the most important themes that the show has to offer, and a lot of emotional trials for our characters. Entire characters and stories are even lifted from the source material, to make time for the long battles after battles, which don’t amount to anything if the story becomes hard to follow.
I accept the beautifully orchestrated sequences that stand alone, and insert them into the fifty episode series, before thinking of this trilogy as a true retelling of Zeta Gundam.